2005-01 Soy Sauce Quality Credit Evaluation Report - World Credit Organization

2005-01 Soy Sauce Quality Credit Evaluation Report

Chapter 1, Implementation Background of Product Quality Credit Evaluation

1. Introduction to ICE8000 International Credit Standard System and Product Quality Evaluation Standard

The ICE8000 international credit standard system is a series of standards for credit evaluation, credit supervision, credit information dissemination, and professional qualification assessment issued by the World Credit Organization [WCO] and the International Integrity Enterprise Association [ICEA], which belong to organizations and individuals. The standard of conduct is also an international universal standard formulated by the Chinese. The ICE8000 family of standards is mainly released to promote social integrity and reduce social and economic transaction costs. It is famous for its fairness, openness in assessment and supervision, and quick and severe punishment for breach of trust. It is a measure of the integrity of various organizations. A kind of recognition, promotion and guarantee, which is the cornerstone of establishing mutual trust in economic transactions or other activities. The ICE8000 international credit standard system does not put forward specific performance and technical index requirements for the products and services of the organization, but requires the organization to be responsible to customers and the society for the quality and defects of products and services, and to be honest and creditable in the process of sales or services , not to deceive and mislead customers. The ICE8000 international credit standard system does not pay attention to the intermediate process of the organization's products and services, but to the organization's commitment and the results of commitment fulfillment.

"ICE8000: 2005038 Product Quality Evaluation Standard" is a public welfare credit evaluation standard among the ICE8000 family of standards. Its main purpose is to assist governments of various countries in product quality supervision, urge various enterprises to pay attention to product quality, and protect consumers' lives and health and other rights and interests, promote social integrity, and standardize the product quality public welfare credit evaluation behavior of ICE8000 credit institutions.

2. Characteristics of ICE8000 product quality evaluation

1. Compared with commercial credit evaluation, ICE8000 public welfare product quality evaluation does not charge the evaluated object, and its funds come from the manuscript fee income after the release of the credit evaluation report (it requires the media that publishes and reprints the credit evaluation report to pay the manuscript fee) , social donations and international integrity funds to make up the difference, and the management of its funds is completely open to the public. This model is known as: the organization and implementation of credit institutions, the media pays the bill, and the public benefits.

2. Donors cannot attempt to know or influence the selection of evaluation products and evaluation results. In order to prevent donors from attempting to influence the evaluation product selection and evaluation results, "ICE8000: 2005038 Product Quality Evaluation Standards" stipulates that organizations and individuals providing donations shall not seek to know undisclosed credit evaluation implementation plans and implementation plans, and shall not use Donate as a condition to try to know or influence the selection of evaluation products and evaluation results, otherwise, verbal warnings, public warnings, and public exposure will be punished.

3. The process of ICE8000 public welfare product quality evaluation is scientific. Each credit evaluation implementation plan is kept confidential before and during the implementation. Personnel follow up and monitor.

Third, the significance of this credit evaluation

"Maintaining the legitimate rights and interests of consumers is the common responsibility of the whole society. The state encourages and supports all organizations and individuals to conduct social supervision over behaviors that harm consumers' legitimate rights and interests (Article 6 of the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumers' Rights and Interests)." This credit evaluation is the first time for a credit institution in China to conduct a fair, open, neutral, and objective credit evaluation and supervision of product quality, marking that China's credit institutions officially use the social credit system to assist the Chinese government and other social organizations The beginning of product safety and protection of consumer rights.

Chapter II Implementation of Credit Evaluation

1. The organization and implementation organization of this credit evaluation

This evaluation activity is authorized and guided by the World Credit Organization [WCO], the International Integrity Enterprise Association [ICEA] and the Beijing Representative Office of the United States World Credit Organization [WCO] Co., Ltd. The specific implementation agencies are as follows:

1. Henriette (Beijing) Credit Rating Office (a special authorized unit of the World Credit Organization [WCO]).

2. Onast (Beijing) Credit Rating Co., Ltd. (a general authorized unit of the World Credit Organization [WCO]).

2. Selection of social certification agencies

1. Product quality inspection agency: Beijing Miyun County Product Quality Supervision and Inspection Institute

Tel: 010-69087607 Contact: Mr. Shi

2. Notary agency: Beijing Miyun County Notary Office

Tel: 010-69085671 Contact: Mr. Zhang, Mr. Feng

3. Projects notarized by notary institutions

The notarization agency will notarize the three items of sample purchase, sample title, and sample delivery, so as to show the society that the samples are actually purchased, the sample titles are correct, and the samples are actually submitted for inspection.

Four. Products and product testing items

Considering that soy sauce is one of the products most closely related to people's life, we determined that the product to be tested was soy sauce, and decided to test amino acid nitrogen (g/100ml), sodium benzoate (g/kg), total bacterial colony (cfu/ ml), coliform bacteria (MPN/100ml), pathogenic bacteria, and sensory characteristics (color, aroma, taste, body shape) and other six important indicators of soy sauce.

V. Implementation process of product quality credit evaluation

1. Product sampling

On November 22, 2005, three staff members of international credit institutions (respectively: Henriette (Beijing) Credit Evaluation Firm Jia Shuyan International Certified Credit Accountant [ICCA], Liu Jibin International Credit Administrator [ICA], Onas Special (Beijing) Credit Rating Co., Ltd. (Beijing) Credit Rating Co., Ltd. Du Yun (International Credit Administrator [ICA]) and two notaries Zhang Zhenshun and Feng Ruide from the notary office formed a sampling team, and conducted sampling according to the list of supermarkets. After obtaining relevant sales invoices and sales receipts, the The relevant information of the sample shall be recorded in time and sealed for numbering (Note: when sealing, the sample label shall be removed or covered, and then numbered to make a blind sample. The notary party and the credit institution shall each hold a copy of the verification list, which shall be signed by both parties) . On the same day after the sampling is completed, the staff of the credit institution and the notary will promptly send the sample to the notary office of Miyun County, Beijing for sealing.

In order to reflect the social representativeness of the products, 10 high-, medium-, and low-end brands were selected for the brands. Samples are selected from various representative supermarkets in Beijing, roughly according to Beijing's geographical location (east, west, south, north, middle), supermarket scale (large, medium, small), and supermarket nature (state-owned, private, foreign) , see Table 2-1 for details.

Table 2-1: Sampling Form of Soy Sauce

2. Sample inspection

On November 23, 2005, the staff of the credit agency and the notary personnel sent the sealed samples to the Beijing Miyun County Product Quality Supervision and Inspection Institute, signed an entrusted inspection agreement and handed over the inspection to the technical personnel of the inspection institute.

3. The testing agency issues the testing results

After the results of the blind sample test come out, the credit institution will provide the testing agency with a sample verification list, and the testing agency will issue an inspection report based on the sample verification list and prepared samples.

Chapter 3 Credit Evaluation Results and Integrity Ranking

1. Calculation method of integrity index

1. Promised quality standards: (1) If the quality standard clearly promised by the enterprise is higher than the national standard, the committed quality standard is equal to the quality standard clearly promised by the enterprise; (2) The quality standard clearly promised by the enterprise is lower than the national mandatory standard, The committed quality standard is equal to the national mandatory standard; (3), if the enterprise has not clearly committed to the quality standard, the committed quality standard is equal to the national standard or industry standard. If there is no national standard or industry standard, the committed quality standard is equal to the lowest standard in the same industry.

2. Measured quality standard: the quality standard of the sampled goods that have been actually tested.

3. Commitment deviation value: used to reflect the absolute gap between the actual quality standard of the product and the promised quality standard

For the high-quality indicators, the committed deviation value = the measured quality standard value - the committed quality standard value

For indicators that choose the best from the lowest, the committed deviation value = the promised quality standard value - the measured quality standard value

4. Commitment deviation rate: used to reflect the relative gap between the actual quality of the product and the promised quality. This indicator can compare the integrity of different grades of products.

Commitment deviation rate = commitment deviation value / commitment quality standard value

5. (Single item, single product) integrity index = (single item, single product) commitment deviation rate * 100

6. Comprehensive integrity index = the sum of each project or each product integrity index.

2. Ranking method

1. The single item ranking is to rank each product according to the level of the individual index integrity index of each product;

2. The comprehensive ranking is to rank the manufacturers and sellers according to the level of the comprehensive integrity index.

3. Evaluation results and ranking of individual indicators

The product credit evaluation is based on the product quality standards: GB 18186-2000 "Brewed Soy Sauce" and GB 2717-2003 "Hygienic Standards for Soy Sauce". There are no specific indicators for coliform bacteria, pathogenic bacteria, and sensory characteristics, so they are no longer ranked. The evaluation results and rankings of the three indicators of amino acid nitrogen, sodium benzoate, and the total number of colonies are as follows:

Table 3-1: Amino acid nitrogen (g/100ml) index test results and integrity ranking

Indicator description: Amino acid nitrogen is the essential component of soy sauce and an important indicator of soy sauce quality. When frying, frying, steaming, and cooking dishes, after adding an appropriate amount of soy sauce, the amino acids in the soy sauce react with salt during the cooking process to form amino acid sodium salt (that is, monosodium glutamate) and produce amino acid derivatives during the heating process. This adds a unique flavor to the dish. At the same time, during the cooking process, the amino acids in soy sauce also react chemically with sugar to produce an attractive aroma.

Table 3-2: Sodium benzoate (g/kg) index test results and integrity ranking

Indicator description: Sodium benzoate is a preservative with certain chemical toxicity. The smaller the indicator, the better.

Table 3-3, the total number of bacterial colonies (cfu/ml) index test results and integrity ranking

4. Comprehensive evaluation results and ranking

Based on the comprehensive integrity index, we have ranked product quality, manufacturers, and sellers in terms of integrity. The results are as follows:

Table 3-4: Product Quality Comprehensive Integrity Ranking

Explanation: The integrity index of the product in this table is the sum of the integrity index of the three individual indicators in the product.

Table 3-5: Manufacturer Integrity Ranking

Important note: Using the results of a sampling inspection of a product to evaluate the integrity of a manufacturer, although it is of great significance to "know the whole leopard at a glance", there is also the possibility of partial generalization, so this The rankings are for caution only.

Table 3-6: Vendor Integrity Ranking

Important note: Using the results of a sampling inspection of a product to evaluate the integrity of a seller, although it has the significance of "seeing the whole thing at a glance", there is also the possibility of partial generalization, so this The rankings are for caution only.

Chapter 4 Other things that need to be explained

1. The sources and usage of the funds are as follows:

Second, according to "ICE8000: 2005038 Product Quality Evaluation Standard" Article 13, paragraph 6, "ICE8000: 2005009 Honor List Information Management Standard", Article 4, paragraph 7, all qualified The products and their manufacturers and sellers are all recorded in the ICE8000 international credit standard system honor list information database, and the honorary certificates signed by the World Credit Organization [WCO] are sent to the units that rank first in individual items and the top three in comprehensive rankings .

Third, in order to continue the public welfare product quality evaluation and jointly create a quality and safe life, please reprint the whole or part of this report and pay us the manuscript fee . At the same time, we hope that people from all walks of life who are interested in public welfare will donate generously and provide donations, the amount is not limited.

We will strictly abide by the provisions of "ICE8000: 2005038 Product Quality Evaluation Standard" to manage funds:

1. The source, use and balance of funds are all disclosed to the public.

2. The media and donors who reproduced this report will be publicly commended in the Honor Roll.

3. If the donor requests to conceal his or her name, the association will use the pseudonym provided by the donor when disclosing the sources of funds and publicly commending, and add it in brackets.

4. If you find that we have not used the funds for the specified purpose, you can report to the public security department and pursue legal responsibility as fraud.

Fourth, a dedicated account for manuscript fees and donations:

Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (Beijing Branch), passbook

Number: 0200 2911 0102 3475 571

Account name: Jia Shuyan

Any donor and the media that pays the manuscript fee can request to check the details of the above-mentioned special account. Contribution and donation contact number: mobile phone: 13681406215, email: jyf187@sina.com

V. Thanks

Finally, we would like to thank the five donors, Jia Shuyan, Liu Jibin, He Jianhua, Gao Chuanxiang, and Wang Li. Without their charitable deeds, this event would not be possible. The leaders and staff of the notary office, Henriette (Beijing) Credit Rating Firm, and Onast (Beijing) Credit Rating Co., Ltd. thanked them for their efficient and hard work, which made the event successfully completed.

World Credit Organization [WCO]

January 9, 2006

Welcome to reprint, please indicate the source of the reprint World Credit Organization [WCO]